Helping You Avoid Life's Financial Mistakes

How Cutting Your Available Credit Can Hurt You

In yesterdays post I talked about how age plays a role in your credit score, in today’s post I’m going to discuss what role the amount of credit you have plays a role.

How Cutting Your Available Credit Can Hurt You

Your available credit plays a big role in your credit score, even bigger than the age of your credit.  Cutting your credit available is usually a common pitfall that most people do without even realizing it.

One of the most common reasons people do it though is because they may want to get out of debt, so they cancel their credit cards to stop racking up the debt.  Another way might be if you just didn’t use the card anymore and wanted to cancel it.  I’ve even heard of people who have had their card canceled because the credit card company deemed the card not active enough.

Whatever the reason cutting too much of your credit can have some serious affects on your score unless done properly.

Here’s An Example To Illustrate My Point

Let’s say you have several different forms of credit available.  Below is just an example of what someone might have.

  • Credit Card #1 with $5000 of available credit
  • Home Equity Line Of Credit with $25,000 of available credit
  • Credit Card #2 with $1000 of available credit
  • Department Store Card with $1000 of available credit
  • Credit Card #3 with $500 of available credit

With all the different credit lines available you have $32,500 of available credit.  Let assume in this example that you have no debt on any of these credit lines that means you have 100% available.

Now at this point you should be showing a great credit score but let’s say you decide to cancel your home equity line of credit.  By doing this you would be cutting 77% off thus negatively affecting your credit score, a lot.

Now just because you canceled one credit line doesn’t mean that it’ll affect you the same for canceling a different credit line.  Let’s say you would cancel credit card #3 with $500 of available credit.

This would be a loss of 1.5% of your total credit available.  It would still be a negative effect to your credit score but not as bad as canceling the home equity line of credit.

How To Avoid This Mistake

If you plan on canceling a credit line, close a smaller one first.  As in the example above I would cancel credit card #3 first.  However what if you like credit card #3 because it has some really great benefits.

In this case I would look to canceling the next credit line with the lowest credit available, but what if you really wanted to cancel the home equity line of credit?  In this case I would contact the lender and ask to lower the amount of credit available slowly over time.

If you lower the bigger amount down in smaller increments over time it will affect your credit score but as a result of it being done over time it will not affect your score as bad.  Also remember that if you do cancel or lower any credit lines make sure you do it slowly over a period of time.  This won’t affect you score as much as doing it all at once.

Next time you go to close credit lines remember this article and you won’t have any problems.

Chris

This post was recently featured on The Carnival Of Personal Finance by Budgets Are Sexy.

How To Cancel Your Credit Cards

istock_000006875534xsmall

Every now and then, while we are in the process of getting out of debt, we do things that we think are right but end up costing us in the long run.  One such incident is canceling your credit cards.

For some reason or another we believe that canceling the cards will stop us from spending more money and get us out of debt faster because we won’t have that option to use them.

While that may hold true, there are a couple of things you must consider before you cancel those credit cards.

Consider This…

First, if you cancel your card with a balance on it, the credit bureaus will see this as more debt and less credit hence cutting down your credit score.  What happens is you are in essence increasing your debt-to-credit ratio.  If you don’t know what this is, just know it is just one of the factors considered in your credit report.  

Second, if you close out of too many accounts at once this can also have a huge effect on your score as well.  When closing your credit card accounts there is a specific way to handle this, and if you get it wrong you may end up paying for it down the road.  Follow the steps below and you shouldn’t have any problems.

How To Cancel Your Credit Cards

  1. Pay Off The Balance First.  Before you close any card make sure your balance on the card has been paid in full.  This will ensure that you won’t affect your credit score.  If you’re not sure, give your credit card company a call and they will assist you in finding what your balance is.
  2. Cancel Your Newest Card First.  Once the balance has been paid in full you want to start with your newest card first.  Why that card?  Because cards with a shorter history have less effect on your credit score.  A credit card you may have had for several years will have a more significant effect on your score. 
  3. Cancel Your Next Card 6 Months To A Year Later.  Once you’ve canceled your first card I want you to wait at least 6 months to cancel your next card.  Again, the next card you should cancel is the newest one.  So why wait 6 months to a year?  Because cancelling too much credit at one time will have a negative affect your score. 
  4. Keep Some Credit.  I also recommend not canceling all of your cards as well.  It’s always good to have some active credit which will help you boost up your credit score.  Keep at least one card open and use it every now and then.  A good card to use would be a gas card.  For example I have a Marathon Master Card which I use to get gas with.  This way I get great rebates on my gas and also build up my credit score at the same time.

Share Your Tips

Do you have any tips you would like to share on canceling credit cards?  If so leave a comment here and let us know.

Chris

Canceling