Helping You Avoid Life's Financial Mistakes

Why You Don’t Want To Refinance To Often

Have you refinanced lately?  I know a lot of people have been refinancing lately due to the record low interest rates available.  But is refinancing to often a mistake?  In today’s post I will discuss why this can be a huge financial mistake.

Why You Don’t Want To Refinance

When you refinance your mortgage a whole lot of things happen all at once.  I should know I just recently did this.  Everything from a new payment interest rate, to even a new mortgage program all together.

Besides all the cost of refinancing your mortgage there is one thing you may not have thought of when you refinance.  That is how much interest you will be paying to the banks over the years from refinancing.

When banks designed the amortization system to loaning money out to people they designed it so the banks would make their money first.

So why did the banks design their system like this?

Because they know that when someone get a mortgage they’re not going to stick with it for life.  Think about it.  If you have a mortgage how many times have you refinanced?  Personally I have refinanced now twice and now that I look back at the situation I wished I never would have.

The average family will refinance every three to five years for a multitude of reasons like, a new job, a loss of a job, low rates, consolidating debt, or even to buy a bigger or smaller home.  The point is the reasons are endless and that we will refinance for one reason or another.

Let me illustrate my point with a simple example.

The Refinance Mistake Example

If you look at the illustration below you will see what an average amortization schedule looks like.  This example is of a $200,000 loan at 5.4% amortized at 30 years fixed.

pi_payment_graph1

If you look at the graph you will see that the purple is the interest that you pay to the bank and the lighter color is the principle paid towards the home.   If you’ll notice in the first five years, who is getting most of your payment?

That’s right the bank is getting most of it.  So here’s another question, at what year are you half way paid off on your mortgage?  If you said 15 years you are wrong.  The answer is year 21.  That means it took you 21 years to pay half of your mortgage off and only the last remaining 9 years to pay off the rest.

But here’s the worst part and why most of us don’t get that far.  If we refinance at year 5 do you start your next loan out at year 5?

Nope.

You start at year one again paying all of that interest.  In the example above if you would stick with the mortgage for 30 years you would pay $204,302 in just interest payments to your bank.  This doesn’t count the interest you paid before you refinanced.

Staggering, isn’t it?

How To Avoid This Mistake

There are a few ways to avoid this mistake.  First, you could make one extra mortgage payment a year.  This would cut five years off the life of your loan.

Second you could apply an extra principle payment every month.  In our case we will use the example from above and add an extra $100 a month to are principle.  The result would again cut around 5 years off of the life of the loan.

The final option is to refinance to a shorter mortgage time frame.  For example if you currently have 30 year mortgage and you’ve been paying on it for some time you may be able to refinance down to a 15 year mortgage and not change payments much.

If you’re not sure about an option contact a professional or even leave a comment.

Chris

Mortgage Refinance Tips That Could Save You Thousands


Recently I just got done refinancing my mortgage to something a bit easier to handle.  My last mortgage which was an option arm mortgage and was giving me a few issues I was beginning to get a bit uncomfortable with.

Things like adjusting payments and rising interest rates started to get me thinking about the possibility of refinancing my mortgage.  So I called my current lender and decide to see what they could do for me.  Also after refinancing I talked to my title agent who closed the loan for me and she was telling me she was closing around 8 loans herself a day and refinances were becoming increasingly popular again.

So in this post I decide to go over some of the basics of refinancing that I learned from my recent refinance experience.  Also I included a few tips of things you should look for.

Why Do You Want To Refinance?

As I explained above I had certain reasons why I wanted to refinance.  It wasn’t particularly because of the rate or my payment amount.  My situation had more to do with the amount of debt I had and my payment and rate fluctuations.

First off I had a few credit card debts with interest rates that were less than desirable and a HELOC or home equity line of credit that had a high interest rate as well.  By combining these two debts into my loan I would cut down my interest and save more.

Second the mortgage wasn’t fixed and my payment and rates were jumping all around.  This became very tough to handle because I didn’t always know what to expect every month.  The payment would be more on one month and less the next.

So before you decide to refinance ask yourself why.  Is it for a better payment, better rate, no more PMI insurance, what is the reasons.  Then decide what you will gain out of refinancing and is that gain big enough for you to really refinance.

So before you do here are a few things you should know before you refinance.

12 Refinance Tips And Things You Should Know

  • Debt ratio. Your debt ratio is your debt over your income.  Lenders and banks use this to see if you have to much debt to qualify for your loan.  Typically you don’t want more than a 36% debt ratio.  The less your debt ratio the better you will qualify the less you will have to pay.
  • Credit score. Again this is something that your bank or lender will take very seriously.  Try to be above 700 or better.  This will again increase your odds of getting the loan.
  • Appraisal. With the current situation as of this post that the housing market is facing having a good home value is very important.  As in my case my value has gone up because of my location for one but also because I had done some home improvement projects that have added some great value to my home.  You should also know that certain lenders will require you to pay for the appraisal up front but may be included into the loan after you close.  However if don’t happen to close you will lose the money you paid in for the appraisal.
  • Review your good faith estimate. Shortly after you fill out the loan application the lender will send you a good faith estimate with in a few short days.  Though most of this may look Greek to you go over it and see what your total closing cost will be.  If their is something that you don’t understand call you loan officer and ask.  Don’t sign something that you don’t know what it is.
  • Know what your closing cost is. Typically closing cost will range differently from one lender to the next but after comparing the actually HUD statements I see the typical closing cost around $3000 to $3500.  Also know that if the lender said it would be only so much to close and it’s a lot high than they originally said you may want to reconsider closing on the loan.
  • Are you saving any money. Lenders like to see you saving money not just spending it all.  Proving this will gain you a lot of credibility.
  • Don’t miss a payment. This is a big NO NO.  Missing one payment is a good way to get on a lenders bad side.  This will show them that you can’t make your payments on time therefore cannot be trusted.  This is also a good way to kill your credit report as well.
  • What kind of asset do you have. Things like your 401k, IRAs, Mutual Funds, Annuities, and even the cash value in your life insurance policy can go a long way for lenders giving you a loan.
  • Last 3 months bank statements. This is a normal requirement for any lender.  They will use this information to see how you spend your money and see how much you have saved up.
  • Last two years W-2 statements. Lenders need these to know how much money you made in the previous two years at your current job.  However if you have currently just changed jobs or got laid off getting a loan my be tough to do.  If you are planning to change jobs you may want to refinance first.
  • Have at least 2 months worth of pay stubs. This is a common item asked for when you are considering refinancing.  This item and the last two will be needed for the underwriting process to be complete.  Also know that lenders will usually only count the first 40 hours of your work week and no over time unless it can be proven that you are getting a certain amount of hours every week for the last two years.
  • Compare lenders. Comparing lenders is always a good idea just to see what others are offering.  Not all lenders charge the same.  Compare at least 3 different lenders and see what you can save.

Are You Thinking About Refinancing?

Refinancing can be bit of a headache but if you don’t know what your doing but following a few of the tips above can save time and a lot of money.  If you are planning on refinancing or have some more tips to share feel free to leave a comment.

To a good refinance,

Chris

This post was recently featured on The Carnival of Personal Finance with Pecuniarities.

Financial Money Traps: The Option Arm Mortgage Disaster

Today is the financial post in the Financial Money Trap Series of money traps I’ve personal fallen into and originally this was only to be a 2 post series but I felt this last post had to be said.  In the first post I talked about a timeshare trap I fell into, and the second post talks about the credit card traps I’ve fallen into.

Today’s post is about a mortgage trap I fell into.  This trap could have been much worse but I will explain what I did to prevent them from getting any worse than it really was.

The Option Arm Mortgage Trap And How It Works

Of all the different types of mortgages out there you defiantly need to watch out for this one.  Now I’m not saying this is a bad mortgage.  What I am saying is that this is a mortgage for only the most sophisticated people who are can take bigger risk and fully understand how this mortgage works.

The Option Arm Mortgage is unlike any other mortgage out there.  All mortgages have a single payment and an interest rate.  Sounds pretty simple but a Option Arm has an option of 4 different payments you can make on it.

  • The first two payments are the 15 year payment, and a 30 year payment.  Both of which are like paying on a 15 and 30 year loan except the interest rates are variable and can adjust on a monthly basis. 
  • The third payment option is an interest only payment.  On this payment you are only paying the interest and no principle on the actual mortgage.  This payment can adjust monthly as well.
  • The fourth payment is called a minimum payment.  This payment will actually be less than the interest payment.  Though this payment does not usually adjust monthly.  It usually can only adjust around 7.5% per year of the payment not the interest rate .  So if you have a $500 minimum payment the next year the highest the loan could adjust to is $537.50. 

How This Mortgage Was Designed To Work

When I first got the option arm mortgage I learned their was two different ways to use this loan. 

  1. The way lenders prefer you to use this loan is for you to pay either the 30 year or 15 year payment like you normally would but if thing would happen to get tight and couldn’t make those two payments you could pay the interest only payment or if things were very tight you could make the minimum payment. 
  2. The second way to use the option arm loan is to pay either the interest only payment or the minimum payment and save the difference you would be paying on your 30 year or 15 year payment aside into a separate savings account.  Why do this?  So you have easy liquidity on your money just in case you lost your job or had a dire emergency.  Then after saving the extra cash and gaining a little interest on it after 30 years you can take that cash you have saved and pay off the mortgage in full.

The Problem With The Option Arm Mortgage

Sometimes things sound great in theory but in reality they just don’t work.  In the case with the option arm mortgage it couldn’t be more true.  Here’s the problems with this mortgage.

  • You could pay the 30 year or 15 year payment option and only pay the minimum or interest only when you needed to but the issue I’ve seen here is that people will get stuck on paying the interest only or worse the minimum payment and eventually dig a hole so deep that they can’t even pay the 30 or 15 year payment. 
  • In the second way to pay off the mortgage you have to set up a savings account to set the money aside so you can keep your fingers off of it.  However, the problem is that the mortgage lender only does mortgages.  So this pretty much leaves you to figure out where to save the money but 9 times out of 10 you may spend all of the money before you save it.
  • And last but not least the biggest problem is that the minimum payment on the option arm loan is a negative amortization payment.  What this means is that you are paying less than the interest due and therefore add the difference between the interest only and minimum payment to your loan balance.  Yes you heard me right your loan balance will go up.  After 4 years of having this loan I ended up adding $4000 to my loan balance.  What a shock this was.

Have You Been In This Mortgage Trap?

Again this mortgage is not for everyone but more important knowing all the risk involved.  Have you ever been in this type of mortgage before?   Leave a comment and let me know how it worked out for you.

This post was featured on the Carnival of Personal Finance by The Fraud Files Blog.